The cash distributions and shares in companies differ in general, as shareholders receive either cash directly or shares in the company. Although these distributions operate in the same way and the amount of profits distributed to shareholders does not change, the difference lies in whether the investor will receive cash or shares in the company.
What is the difference between cash distributions and shares?
Cash distribution: The goal of cash distribution is to generate income. The cash amount is deposited directly into the investor’s pocket, usually through the account they created with their broker. The investor can spend this amount however they choose.
Companies must retain enough cash in each quarter to distribute dividends, which means they need to maintain more stable profit structures. This reminds the people at the top that they are there to create wealth for business owners, not just to grow their own empire.
This also prevents the accumulation of cash that could be squandered by a CEO who feels pressured to take action or prove their leadership ability.
Note: Companies that pay cash dividends often do not experience significant declines in bear markets since the distribution yield acts as a safety cushion.
Stock distribution: Stock distribution, whether paid directly by the company or equated by the investor, helps to increase investments. If an investor has confidence in long-term investment potential, they often prefer growth opportunities in stock distributions.
The IRS says that most distributions are paid in cash. This is the most common way to convert profits into shareholder returns. However, cash distributions are less common in sectors and companies that focus more on growth than profit. These companies may invest their profits into growth or share buybacks instead of dividends.
Risk: There are no specific risks associated with cash distributions since you are being paid in cash. The only risk is the same inflation risk that affects any cash savings you hold.
With stock distributions, there are more risks to consider. If the stock price drops after the distribution is paid, you would have more money from simple cash distribution. However, this risk can also work in your favor, just like any other way you invest your money. If the stock price rises after you receive your share of the profits, the distribution could be higher than it would have been in the case of cash dividends.
Which is suitable for you?
In most cases, you will not have a choice regarding how to receive the distribution. Also, remember that these two options are similar. Income, whether cash or stock, will be taxed as ordinary income at your regular income tax rate unless the distributions are “qualified.” Qualified distributions are those that come from American companies that you have owned for at least 61 days. These qualified distributions are taxed at a lower rate, either 0%, 15%, or 20%.
The real choice is whether you will decide to reinvest your cash distributions or sell your stock distributions for cash. Here are some factors to consider if you are unsure of the right option for you.
When do cash distributions work best?
You may prefer to receive a cash payout if you are investing for income. You may also choose cash if you prefer to invest in another venture.
Cash distributions can be a significant morale boost for shareholders in the company. Imagine a retired teacher living in the suburbs with a portfolio worth $500,000. A significant market drop of 20% would cause an illusory loss and anxiety for the teacher, but perhaps only if they had money in companies that do not offer cash distributions. By receiving some cash from a well-performing stock, that teacher will know they are still getting some reward from their money.
They are not bothered by the same loss if they decide to invest in stocks that provide them with income, such as dividends with an average yield of 4%. They would be happy with a cash distribution of $20,000 from the profits they receive each year. The share in profits helps them feel like they have a stake in a profitable venture rather than being individuals exposed to stock market fluctuations.
Note: There are other times when stock distributions may not be good. If the stocks are overvalued, you may want to hold cash distributions even if you plan to reinvest the money in the future.
When do stock distributions work best?
Investing is the process of putting money to work today for you, not just now but in the future for you and your loved ones. Growth in the company should lead to future changes in your lifestyle, either in the form of better things or financial freedom.
If you are focused on growth and trust the venture you put your money in, you might prefer to put your cash distributions into more stocks to increase your gains.
A choice that combines both
Instead of choosing one of the options, you might prefer to invest in a company that buys back its shares to remove those shares from the market. This action often leads to an increase in stock value. Some of these companies may also offer dividends.
Some executives in companies may push their boards to keep dividends low and put the money back into the company through real estate, plants, equipment, and employees. This is not the same as buying back shares, but it achieves a similar goal for company growth.
Stock buybacks are a more tax-efficient way to return capital to shareholders because they won’t have to pay taxes on those buybacks. However, their share in the company increases. This can lead to more profits and cash distributions on your shares, even if sales or overall profits never increase.
Conclusion
Most people who receive cash distributions will find that they are added to their brokerage account, instead of stock distributions that give shares instead of cash payments. However, if you prefer stock distributions, you can always buy more shares with the cash you receive. Some companies may buy back shares instead of paying dividends, which increases the value of the stocks.
The takeaway
You might prefer to receive cash dividends if you are an investor who needs cash now to live, or if you want to ensure that you can put excess profit where you want it. You may want to invest your money in a company that buys back its shares if you believe that companies can achieve greater profits by reinvesting to achieve high returns on equity with little debt. If the company pays dividends but you prefer more shares, you can always reinvest your profits to repeat the stock distribution.
Source: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/cash-dividends-vs-share-repurchases-357439
Leave a Reply