!Discover over 1,000 fresh articles every day

Get all the latest

نحن لا نرسل البريد العشوائي! اقرأ سياسة الخصوصية الخاصة بنا لمزيد من المعلومات.

Performance of a New Test to Measure Antibodies Inhibiting the Thyroid Gland in Patients with Autoimmune Thyroid Disorders

Autoimmune thyroid disorders are among the most common immune system disorders, significantly affecting individuals’ health, particularly women in midlife. In this article, we will review an innovative study aimed at improving the diagnosis of these conditions through the development of a new test called “Turbo™”. The primary goal of this test is to measure inhibitory antibodies (TBI) accurately and rapidly, contributing to a better understanding of thyroid function in patients. We will discuss the results of analytical performance studies of the new test compared to traditional methods, as well as its potential use in the management and treatment of autoimmune thyroid disease cases. Stay tuned to explore scientific developments that may change how we deal with these disorders.

Antibodies Associated with Autoimmune Thyroid Disease

The antibodies associated with autoimmune thyroid diseases are considered among the most important factors affecting thyroid function. These diseases include conditions like Hashimoto’s thyroiditis and Graves’ disease, which are the most common autoimmune disorders. Antibodies to thyroid-stimulating hormone receptors (TSH-R) are found in various groups of these patients and may contribute to thyroid dysfunction. Inhibitory antibodies (TBI) are present in 10%-15% of patients with these disorders, indicating their significant role in affecting thyroid function.

Stimulating antibodies (TSI) represent another type of antibody that stimulates the thyroid glands and leads to an increased secretion of thyroid hormones such as T3 and T4. In their case, these antibodies may cause hyperthyroidism. On the other hand, inhibitory antibodies work to reduce stimulation by inhibiting TSH receptors, leading to decreased production of thyroid hormones. This balance between stimulating and inhibitory antibodies plays a crucial role in causing thyroid pathologies, as the transition between these types of antibodies can lead to changes in patient conditions, such as shifting from hyperthyroidism to hypothyroidism, especially during treatment.

These dynamics between antibodies highlight the importance of conducting clinical analyses to identify the types of antibodies present, which helps guide treatment strategies appropriately. It is also essential to monitor the nature of the interactions occurring during treatment, as some individuals may experience changes in their antibody response due to therapy.

Analysis and Evaluation in New Bioassays

The precise analysis of antibodies associated with thyroid diseases is conducted using new techniques such as Turbo™ TBI. This test is characterized by its simplicity and rapid execution, allowing for more effective analyses by practitioners. This test shows a higher capacity to detect inhibitory antibodies compared to traditional methods, such as immunoassay tests (TSH-R-Ab), highlighting advancements in this field for clinical applications.

A large-scale study involving 1,011 patients with immune and thyroid disorders was conducted. The results revealed 131 patients positive for inhibitory antibodies, with a significant distribution in thyroid function status among the patients. 70.3% of the patients had hypothyroidism, while 22% were in a normal state, and 7.5% were suffering from hyperthyroidism. These results indicate the need for a deeper understanding of the roles played by antibodies in various thyroid function states to ensure precise treatment delivery.

The new bioassays also contribute to enhancing the accuracy and quality of the information extracted from samples based on measures of secondary cell response, as utilizing the cAMP level measurement technique allows for a broader and more comprehensive study of existing mechanisms in various laboratory environments. This enhances researchers’ ability to select appropriate therapeutic patterns, thereby improving patients’ response rates.

Study

Case and Clinical Findings

The case study highlights the importance of paying attention to clinical factors and laboratory tests during diagnosis. Evaluation of patients with thyroid gland syndromes needs to be accurate and comprehensive, including all laboratory results related to thyroid functions alongside the present antibodies. Data such as thyroid hormone concentrations and TSH levels are critical factors in determining appropriate treatment, requiring a good monitoring system for the interaction between these data.

Moreover, in-depth analysis of clinical data is linked to a comprehensive understanding of the medical issues affecting those patients. This approach requires collaboration between immunology specialists and endocrinologists, enhancing mutual understanding of the impact that immune disorders can have on thyroid function. Adherence to good practices in diagnosis and treatment can improve the quality of life for patients, facilitating integrated healthcare.

The use of techniques such as Turbo™ and Thyretain® offers an opportunity to enhance the ability to identify different antibody profiles quantitatively. Accurate measurement of these indicators relied upon in therapeutic strategies is very beneficial. Documenting this process leads to the provision of systems based on standard information regarding patient response monitoring and reading.

Results and Analytical Procedures

The study was conducted on a group of 1011 patients with autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) with the aim of assessing the effectiveness and differences of several methods to determine thyroid antibody levels. The analysis included a comparison of results using an unpaired t-test. The results were plotted on a graph, utilizing the Turbo™ LBI system to measure dilution levels in two samples. The average values of relative light units (RLU) were graphically represented using GraphPad Prism 10. The significance level (α) was set at 0.05. Correlations and graphical representations were created using IBM SPSS Statistics 23 and MedCalc. The results included demographic and clinical information about the patients, with an average disease duration of 5 years and ages ranging from 13 to 47.5 years for males and females. 212 samples from patients were classified as positive, measured using various antibody measurement methods. Of these, 70.3% of the samples showed hypothyroidism, while 22% were stable and 7.5% were hyperactive.

Antibody Measurement Methods

Three different tests were used to measure the presence of antibodies (TSH-R-Ab) in blood samples. All tests yielded negative results in samples from 90 healthy individuals. However, there was a significant variation in results when using different antibody methods. The Turbo™ test demonstrated a significant discrimination ability, successfully detecting antibodies in 100% of positive samples, while other tests like Thyretain® and TRAb showed lower sensitivity levels. The results indicated a convergence between Turbo™ and Thyretain® results in measuring antibodies, highlighting the effectiveness of Turbo™ in providing accurate and fast results, making it a reliable tool for clinical diagnosis and treatment.

Statistical Analyses and Correlations

The statistical analyses included comparing the results of various antibody tests using sensitivity and specificity metrics. The Turbo™ test showed a 63.2% positive agreement with antibody results, while there were lesser agreements with other methods. The ROC curve was used to assess analytical performance, with Turbo™ showing a significant advantage over Thyretain®. The analyses also showed rapid differences in average value results among the various tests, reflecting the robustness of the antibodies and their diagnostic effectiveness. Through these analyses, the importance of Turbo™ as a reliable option for antibody analysis was reinforced, potentially changing the way autoimmune thyroid conditions are diagnosed and treated.

Applications

Clinical and Future Estimates

The Turbo™ test boasts significant features that make it more effective in clinical environments. The ability to measure a larger array of samples at once helps expedite the diagnostic steps for treatment. Clinics and medical centers are eager to leverage these features to provide accurate and rapid diagnoses for patients. Additionally, the speed of obtaining results contributes to reducing the burden on patients and enhancing the early diagnosis of thyroid-related diseases, ultimately improving patient health. Some applications may include using Turbo™ to identify cases of thyroid deficiency or hyperactivity, contributing to the success of personalized treatment strategies, and conducting future studies to expand the test’s uses in evaluating various thyroid-related medical conditions.

Risks and Necessary Standards

Despite the numerous benefits of using the Turbo™ test, there is a need to consider a set of standards and risks before fully adopting it. Experimental medicine and diagnostic teams must be prepared to validate the data and analyze all factors affecting test results. Attention to sample quality and methods of storage and transport is essential to maintain result accuracy. Furthermore, clear protocols should be established to ensure that all laboratory staff are well trained in using this new technology. Continuous improvement and innovative standards in measuring antibodies will ultimately lead to better outcomes in diagnosis and treatment, ensuring high-quality healthcare for patients suffering from thyroid disorders. Working to improve and increase the effectiveness of these methods should be part of an ambitious integrated institutional strategy.

Comparative Analysis Between Turbo™ Test and Thyretain® Test

The Turbo™ test is a new technique developed to assess thyroid activity by measuring antibodies connected to TSH receptors. This test is distinguished by the low sample volume required, needing only 10 microliters of patient serum, compared to the 30 microliters required for the Thyretain® test. This achievement showcases the significant benefit of using electronic pipettes, making sample handling easier and reducing the likelihood of error during the draw process. Additionally, HCBS-TSH-R-Mc4 cells, which have been produced through gene transfer, have been utilized, enhancing the effectiveness of this test.

Studies have shown that the response of HCBS-TSH-R-Mc4 cells to bovine TSH levels was less compared to wild Mc4 cells, indicating important differences in response. The results also showed that the cells used in Turbo™ improved in their response to the M22 monoclonal antibodies. Despite the different outcomes in TSH responses, the analytical performance between Turbo™ and Thyretain® was similar, making Turbo™ an effective and cost-efficient alternative.

Importance of Functional Antibody Measurement During Pregnancy

Measuring functional antibodies during pregnancy is crucial, especially for women suffering from autoimmune thyroid diseases. Previous studies have revealed that fetal thyroid dysfunction can occur due to the transfer of functional TSH-R-Ab antibodies from the mother to the child. These conditions can lead to severe health issues, such as hypothyroidism in newborns. Physicians are currently advised to measure functional antibodies as part of the pregnancy care for women with thyroid disorders, such as Graves’ disease and/or Hashimoto’s.

The evidence underscores the need for close monitoring by healthcare providers, as positive antibody results may lead to additional measures to ensure the health of both mother and child. For example, children born to mothers with Graves’ disease may require thorough assessments of thyroid function, even when the mother’s symptoms are well-controlled. This highlights the importance of measuring functional antibodies in managing and monitoring thyroid health and its implications for reproduction.

Evolution

Diagnostic Tests for Autoimmune Thyroid Disease AITD

There is an increasing need for modern techniques to understand and monitor autoimmune thyroid diseases, especially with the rising cases of conditions like Graves’ disease and Hashimoto’s disease. Data derived from Turbo™ and Thyretain® tests provide unique insights into disease severity and antibody status in the clinical field. This information highlights significant differences between patients with hypothyroidism and those without, as the Turbo™ test demonstrates higher accuracy in identifying patients with hypothyroidism compared to Thyretain®.

During the analyses, Turbo™ showed remarkable capability in identifying patients with hypothyroidism across different ranges of percentage inhibition. This precise population identification aligns with the high rates of accuracy and sensitivity for the Turbo™ test. Innovations in testing techniques, including rapid performance and standardization, reduce burdens and enhance the direct understanding of diseases.

Conclusions on the Clinical Implementation of the Turbo™ Test

Highlighting the clinical implementation of the Turbo™ test is a central step towards improving the diagnosis and monitoring of thyroid diseases. The good performance of the test in terms of sensitivity and specificity enhances its status as an effective diagnostic tool. Additionally, the ability to use smaller sample sizes is a noteworthy advantage, as it saves time and financial resources, thereby improving the quality of healthcare.

Data show that the test achieves good concordance with other immunological tests, enhancing the reliability of the provided data. Therefore, Turbo™ TBI is considered a promising choice for detecting thyroid diseases, contributing to more accurate and effective diagnosis. As research progresses, the Turbo™ test is expected to be improved to meet the needs of various different clinical applications.

Thyroid Immune Disorders

Thyroid immune disorders are among the most common immune disorders, particularly in middle-aged women. These disorders include conditions such as Hashimoto’s thyroiditis and Graves’ disease, both of which lead to dysfunction of the thyroid gland, creating a state of either hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism. Diagnosing these diseases requires careful assessment of a number of clinical and biological factors, including thyroid hormone levels and associated antibodies, which play a crucial role in forming the clinical picture of the disease, as well as determining the type of therapy applied.

Antibodies against thyroid-stimulating hormone receptors (TSH-R) play a central role in these diseases, exhibiting variable functions between stimulation and inhibition, adversely affecting metabolic activity in thyroid cells. For example, activating antibodies lead to increased production of thyroid hormones, while inhibiting antibodies may cause a deficiency in the secretion of these hormones, resulting in health issues such as malignancy. Furthermore, levels of these antibodies may change during treatment, necessitating continuous monitoring to determine the effectiveness of the therapies used.

Evaluation of Serum Elements and Antibody Transition

Recent studies indicate the importance of accurate evaluation of serum elements such as thyroid hormones and autoantibodies in managing Graves’ disease. Levels of these antibodies can be measured as part of the treatment strategy, showing significant effects on patients’ responses to treatment. For instance, when treating Graves’ disease with antithyroid medications, the type of antibodies may shift from activating to inhibiting. This transition has significant implications for how the disease is managed and the therapeutic response.

Research aims to understand how antibody levels change during treatment, including the possibility of transition from one type of antibody to another. This knowledge is essential as it may reflect a shift in the nature of the disease, prompting adjustments in patients’ treatment plans to ensure optimal outcomes. These tests should be a regular part of patient follow-up to avoid any potential complications.

Interaction

The Complex Between Antibodies and Signaling Pathways

The interaction between antibodies and TSH receptors indicates the presence of complex signaling pathways affecting thyroid function. Antibodies that stimulate TSH-R activate signaling pathways by influencing cAMP levels, which promotes increased production of thyroid hormones. Conversely, immunosuppressive antibodies lead to reduced production of these hormones by blocking the normal binding of thyroid-stimulating hormone.

These interactions play a crucial role in determining whether one will exhibit hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism. Therefore, it is essential to develop new methods for accurately assessing these immune functions to improve diagnosis and treatment. For example, new tests have been developed based on cAMP levels to more easily and accurately determine the various activities of antibodies.

New Research in Measuring Thyroid-Inhibiting Antibodies

Recent developments in measuring thyroid-inhibiting antibodies represent a significant advancement in understanding these immune disorders. A new testing system has been developed that measures cAMP levels in a faster and less complex manner, increasing the testing capacity and facilitating its use in a clinical context. This system aims to improve result accuracy and reduce the time required to obtain them, assisting physicians in making quicker and more informed decisions.

These developments are not only important for doctors but also for patients, as they can lead to more precise and successful treatment plans. This trend towards innovation in biological testing reflects the medical community’s commitment to better understanding these diseases and treating them more effectively.

Future Improvements in Understanding Causes and Treatment Impact

In the future, ongoing research is expected to contribute to deeper insights into the possible causes of thyroid autoimmune diseases and the impact of the treatments used. It is important to understand how environmental, genetic, and external factors interact with these disorders. This knowledge can aid in developing new treatment strategies aimed at improving the quality of life for patients suffering from thyroid autoimmune disorders.

There is also an urgent need for further studies to understand the effects of current treatments and to know how to enhance them. A deep understanding of individual differences in patient responses to treatment can help provide more personalized care and increase the likelihood of treatment success.

Good Clinical Practices in Medical Research

Practicing good clinical practices (GCP) is essential in medical research to ensure the protection of the rights of study participants and the quality of the collected data. In these contexts, acquiring informed consent from all participants, whether they are patients or healthy individuals, is emphasized. These procedures fall within an ethical framework outlined by the Helsinki Declaration, which sets ethical guidelines for research involving humans. These principles include the necessity for study participants to be fully aware of the risks and benefits of research, highlighting the importance of transparency in the research process. In the mentioned study, blood samples were collected from patients with autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD) and their families, reflecting the researchers’ commitment to good clinical practices.

Sample Testing and the Use of New Methods

Serum samples from AITD patients were tested using innovative methods such as dual-base cell-dependent spectroscopy. These methods involve new tests like “Turbo™ TBI” and “Thyretain® TBI,” which are used to measure thyroid hormone-related activity. Levels of correlate hormones such as TSH, T4, and T3 are measured to analyze thyroid function. By studying 180 samples in other serum analysis studies, levels of antibodies like TPO and Tg were assessed, providing the necessary information to diagnose AITD. These modern techniques enhance the accuracy and reliability of tests, contributing to improved healthcare.

Development

Biomarker GS-22F

The GS-22F biomarker technology represents a significant step in improving the accuracy of measuring intracellular values. Chinese cloned liver cells are used to collect cAMP levels, allowing for a more precise analysis of hormonal activity. GS-22F outperforms previous versions of biomarkers in its ability to distinguish between full and partial agonists, providing significant benefits in assessing how cells respond to different hormone levels. At the same time, improving reactivity and variability between different cell types requires the use of specific conversions, which enables the expansion of the mathematical applications of these biomarkers in clinical research.

Statistical Analysis of Results

Data and statistics remain a vital part of clinical research, with Spearman analysis used to compare results between different tests and determine accuracy and reliability. In the study, relationships were developed between the aggregated material and various clinical details, such as factors influencing antibody levels and the accuracy of TBI tests. Results are represented using graphs and through tests such as t-test and Mann-Whitney, providing a comprehensive view of the value of each test and what can be inferred from the data. These analyses highlight the importance of a good understanding of statistical factors in improving treatment strategies and patient healthcare.

Demographic and Clinical Data

The demographic and clinical data provide a real insight into the impact of AITD disease. A group of patients with an average age of 33 years was included, reflecting the most susceptible age group. Thanks to the collection of data from a large number of patients, researchers were able to analyze the relationship between serum levels of TSH, Tg, and TPO and their effect on the patient’s health status. This data reflects the diverse distribution of clinical cases, from patients with hypothyroidism to those suffering from hyperthyroidism, increasing the importance of clinically-based studies.

Test Results and Effectiveness Comparison

The results of the tests are compared among different methods used for data analysis, especially regarding the sensitivity and specificity of the different tests used, such as Turbo™ and Thyretain®. The results indicate a significant difference in sensitivities; the Turbo™ test showed higher effectiveness in identifying positive cases of AITD compared to Thyretain®. These results emphasize the importance of ongoing improvement and development of the tests used in diagnosis and patient monitoring, which could lead to more accurate and effective treatment recommendations.

Performance Analysis of Turbo™ and Thyretain® Tests

Although both tests, Turbo™ and Thyretain®, are used to measure antibodies related to thyroid function, the Turbo™ test shows slightly better performance. Larger effect sizes were identified for the Turbo™ test compared to Thyretain®, with the Turbo™ test showing a marked difference between samples of hypothyroid and non-hypothyroid subjects. These results suggest that Turbo™ may play an important role in more accurately and effectively identifying individuals with thyroid issues.

When the Turbo™ test was applied to a group of patients with autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD), significant differences in the results were observed, while the Thyretain® test did not show that disparity. For instance, in cases associated with low thyroid hormone, the effectiveness of Turbo™ exceeded the expected effectiveness, reflecting its ability to recognize conditions when it comes to diagnosing thyroid issues. The results collected from the two tests indicated that Turbo™ had a higher capacity to differentiate between different samples due to the strong response it exhibited.

Ability to Distinguish Between Sample Types

The Turbo™ test demonstrated a greater capacity to recognize samples with low hormonal activity and samples from healthy thyroid patterns. This is based on the practical data collected, which is crucial in clinical medicine for enhancing the capability to accurately classify patients with thyroid dysfunction. On the other hand, the results from the Thyretain® test showed no psychological differences between hyperthyroid samples and healthy samples, indicating that Turbo™ outperforms Thyretain® in this area.

In

data readings, there were precise measurements of the discriminative ability, where Turbo™ measurements provide data indicating enhanced early and effective diagnosis for patients with a heightened risk. For example, the current dose-response curves of Turbo™ compared to Thyretain® showed greater flexibility and a sensitive response to variable factors in the samples, highlighting the importance of using Turbo™ as an increasingly adopted tool in the healthcare sector.

Challenges of Using Turbo™ Test

Although the Turbo™ test reshapes the landscape of antibody infiltration, there are some challenges associated with its final adoption in clinics. Despite the test demonstrating high accuracy, there is a potential for variables within low negative ranges that may affect the results. These issues require more research and improvements to deliver safe outcomes.

One common issue in antibody tests generally, which requires careful analysis of factors that could affect results, such as medications and environmental factors. Previous data in the current test show that there is no impact of thyroid hormone medications on the test performance, but it is important to continue monitoring to fully understand this relationship.

Clinical Importance of the Test

The Turbo™ test represents a significant advance in the diagnosis and follow-up of thyroid-related diseases, especially among AITD patients. This test has the potential to provide valuable information about patients’ health status based on accurate sample analysis. The time and resource savings in sample preparation and faster results distinguish it from traditional testing methods, enhancing its role in clinics.

Moreover, analysis indicates that the ability to measure antibody levels during pregnancy in patients with AITD can be vital, as thyroid problems have been reported in newborns due to the transfer of antibodies from the mother. Therefore, the focus on measuring functional antibodies in a range of clinical cases continues.

Future Conclusions on Turbo™ Test

The features of the Turbo™ test go beyond performance aspects; they indicate the potential evolution of modern treatment and healthcare approaches. As research continues to establish more controlled links between test results and performance outcomes, Turbo™ could become a standard tool in medical laboratories. The analysis of the information generated from the test indicates a new framework for understanding the relationship between antibodies and their effect on thyroid function.

Ultimately, the successful integration of the Turbo™ test into potential clinical practices will open new horizons for diagnosing diseases and improving outcomes for pregnant women, providing a comprehensive overview for enhancing health outcomes. As testing techniques become more advanced, patient experiences will be crowned with new prospects for therapeutic screening and specialized approaches in treating thyroid-related disorders.

Modern Testing Techniques for Thyroid Diseases

Autoimmune diseases such as Hashimoto’s thyroiditis and others are among the most common health issues affecting the thyroid. Laboratory testing is essential for diagnosing these diseases, requiring accurate and reliable techniques. Several types of tests are available, but in recent years, modern techniques such as Turbo™ TBI have become prominent in this field. This technique offers significant diagnostic benefits compared to traditional tests.

The Turbo™ TBI technique is based on useful measurements to determine the presence of antibodies to thyroid hormone receptors (TRAb), which play a key role in assessing the immune activity of the gland. Although there is a general preference among large laboratories for using automated antibody measurements due to their ease of implementation, Turbo™ TBI offers an effective alternative that is easy to use. Its approved method helps accelerate the diagnostic process, contributing to a more accurate assessment of the patient’s condition.

One of
The prominent benefits of Turbo™ TBI technology are its ability to achieve accurate and reliable results compared to traditional tests such as Thyretain® TBI. Data indicates that Turbo™ TBI boasts an AUC value of 0.833, while Thyretain® TBI had a value of 0.795. This indicates that Turbo™ TBI delivers more accurate results, making it easier to identify cases that are more severe among thyroid-related disorders.

Moreover, the potential integration of this technology into routine clinical tests would enhance the accuracy and efficiency of reaching a flexible diagnosis suitable for autoimmune thyroiditis cases in general and Hashimoto’s thyroiditis cases in particular. With the increasing number of individuals suffering from these diseases, using these tests will significantly contribute to improving healthcare.

The Importance of Data and Ethical Procedures in Clinical Studies

There has been a pressing need to address ethical issues in research and clinical studies, especially when these studies involve humans. Approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee of the Physicians’ Association in Rhineland-Palatinate, demonstrating the researchers’ commitment to recognized ethical standards. Local laws and institutional requirements were followed during the conduct of these studies, providing a safe environment for participants.

The accurate and reliable collection of data contributes to improving research outcomes. The data collected from study participants includes accurate information about their health conditions, along with antibody measurements. This data represents the foundation for clinical decision-making and enhances the quality of care provided to patients.

On the other hand, transparency in presenting data and results is a crucial step toward fostering trust between researchers and the medical community. The authors announced the availability of raw data supporting the study’s conclusions without hesitation, indicating a commitment to integrity and reliability in research. These steps are significant points that benefit the medical community in general, as they contribute to improving diagnostic and treatment methods.

Everyone should be aware of the importance of precise study design characteristics and how ethics play a vital role in the acceptance of research findings. Participants in studies should enjoy their full rights and enough privilege for informed consent, reflecting respect for free choice and for the individuals involved in research.

Financial Support and Its Relationship to Scientific Research

Conducting scientific research requires funding that aligns with the scope of work and the requirements needed to achieve the desired results. Financial support is a critical factor in the success of any research. For example, this study received support from QuidelOrtho Corp in San Diego, California, facilitating the researchers’ work in collecting and analyzing data. However, it is important to emphasize that the presence of funding should not affect the integrity of the research or its results.

Funding expands researchers’ ability to utilize the best techniques and tools, leading to improvements in research quality. The presence of independent funding sources helps create a working environment where researchers can trust their results will remain influential and objective, which is typically not possible when funding comes from conflicting interests.

However, it requires courage and transparency from researchers to disclose funding sources and their potential impacts. Disclosure of funding is essential as it provides the medical community with the opportunity to understand the contexts surrounding studies and address any potential integrity issues.

Furthermore, coordinating efforts between health institutions, researchers, and funding bodies can contribute to developing sustainable studies that effectively and accurately address health challenges.

Source link: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/endocrinology/articles/10.3389/fendo.2024.1463379/full

Artificial intelligence has been used ezycontent


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *